Niche or not? 

20110513: Grandparents Day at LGA  (Photos: Shana Sureck/www.shanasureck.com)

 

What a week!  Pre-Cotillion portraits in my Hartford studio of eleven beautiful young men and women, a pre-Bat Mitzvah portrait of Dvora with her horse Secret by a barn in Westhampton, MA., two big events – a Harold Grinspoon Foundation Teachers Award Banquet and the 2011 Hartford Public Schools Academic Competition, a JCC Big Truck fun fair in West Hartford, a playful, costumed shoot at the University of Hartford highlighting Super Students (seniors with jobs to head into after graduation), a volunteer shoot on Grandparents Day at Lander Grinspoon Academy, and a day’s work in the Bronx on a video documentary about aging.

(Is Taylor elegant, or what??  I can’t wait for the Cotillion in June)

(Dvora, with Secret. I love them together.)

(A Springfield teacher and her pals pose as the sun sets over the mountains behind the Log Cabin in Easthampton.  What a beautiful setting, and what a beautiful tribute to teachers the night was)

(Two Kennelly third graders confer about an answer to a math problem in the Academic Competition)

(An LGA fourth grader, dressed for her role as a nasty princess in a play, shows grandparents one way of doing long division)

(No, I didn’t do the photoshopping! Art Director Stacy Baran did for the upcoming issue of The Observer)

This week rocked!!!!  I was busy.  I loved the events I covered. I had fun! But the very thing I loved – the range of assignments – raised questions for me. My work as a freelancer runs the gamut from non-profits and schools to wedding and bar/bat mitzvahs to news and some corporate work.  Add to that multimedia and some video. Oh, yes, and some teaching. I like the variety.  As a newspaper photographer, I loved that I could be in an elementary school in the morning doing a story on yoga helping kids relax before taking CMT’s and in prison in the afternoon doing a story on overcrowding. I could sit under the basket shooting UConn basketball and follow, in depth over two years, the life of a young woman getting off welfare.  In the business world, however, it seems like a liability to be a generalist, for lack of a better word.  Speciality is the name of the game. Photographers are known for their niche – weddings, portraiture, architecture, sports, corporate.

My question for all of you reading this, especially seasoned photographers in the business, is does one have to have a niche to be financially successful in today’s uncertain economy?

Do I need to identify primarily as a wedding photographer, a corporate photographer, a news photographer (forget it, it doesn’t pay), or can I be a photographer who shoots events and marketing, as well as weddings and bar mitzvahs, with an occassional corporate assignment and a NY Times/AP assignment every now and then?

If every week were as busy as the last week, I might not have to ask this question, but every week isn’t. So, as I look to drum up business to keep a steady work flow throughout the year, I am confused about where to put my energies and how to market myself.  I don’t have one target client.  Or do I?  My ideal client is someone who wants a photojournalist’s eye to help tell the story of their institution, event, or life celebration.  Instead of having a niche, I see myself as a storyteller who, with skill and sensitivity, can translate what is meaningful to a client into great photographs. But can it fly? Is there enough time in the day to keep abreast of all the trends and technologies for each of the particular direction? No, not really.  Is there one simple way to market a way of seeing rather than a niche?  I reach out to you for answers.  Is there a community of like-minded photographers out there who know they’d be bored doing the same thing over and over again?  I know that the best wedding photographers, for instance, don’t get bored, because they keep their vision fresh, but could I?  I don’t know. I’ve never done just one thing.

I know that my love for variety comes with a price.  I had an afternoon coffee last week with a wonderful and talented wedding photographer locally, Sandra Costello.  She’s very savvy businesswise, and when you think of wedding photographers in Northampton, her name will always be among the few that are very well known.  She commands a good price, and for good reason.  She’s good.  She’s got a well known brand doing one thing really well.  That makes marketing and promotion easier, it makes keeping up with trends and technology easier, it probably makes her brain work easier than juggling directions, different kinds of learning, and having no clue what approach to take to marketing.  She knows her audience and is known by her audience.  That’s so key to having a successful business.

Success, I’m learning, has to do not only with talent, but with being THE name -the brand, if you will -that makes you synonymous with your specialty.  When we were both at the newspaper, the name John Long instantly brought to mind great ballet photos.  In Hartford, Carla Ten Eyck=Awesome Weddings. I envy how being the ‘go to’ photographer for a certain niche must simplify certain things enormously – marketing, pricing, workflow, etc.  What I wonder about is whether there can be another successful business model for all of us photojournalists-turned-freelancers entering the marketplace in the past few years as newspapers/magazines downsize and grasp, literally, for their survival. Let’s put our heads together so we can all fly as we go forward!!!!

Any thoughts????  I’m looking forward to hearing from you.

 

 

 



Published on May 24th, 2011 by Shana


Join in on the conversation!
your comments are greatly appreciated...

  • I think the niche called events includes everything and most importantly feeds your creativity.  Doing only one kind of thing isn’t your style anymore. Each of the photos from last week are memorable , stimulating , and heart touching .  When there are enough in circulation, you’ll be the name in creative work.
    It takes a minimum of 3   years to get off the ground  and your doing it. Love, Mary

  • Shana – you are doing stunning work!  Not that that surprises me.  I know that the variety is what keeps you (and all fellow photojournalists) fresh and inspired.  I’m not sure that fitting into a niche right now is right for you.  You do so many things so well. But, I understand that practicality is important since you need a steady income.  Perhaps if you narrowed your focus (no pun intended) to three areas, something might eventually emerge as your niche.  So, let’s say weddings and bar/bat mitzvahs are the most lucrative assignments for you.  Those would be your priority.  Then, I would try and fill in with whatever areas you are most interested in (since we do our best work when our heart is in it) and pursue those kinds of clients.  I’m guessing this is pretty much what you’ve been doing already, but since your passion is so integral to your work, my advice to you is to go with your heart which is, as you said, storytelling. Easier said than done, though, as I’m sure you’d be hard pressed to turn down a corporate job should it come your way.

    Another option would be to specialize for a trial period, let’s say six months or a year, and see what happens.  So you could aggressively pursue weddings and bar/bat mitzvahs and improve your skills in that genre and see what the outcome is over time.  You may find thats your niche.  If not, something else will emerge as your calling.  Think of your career as a work in progress, still evolving.  The answers will come to you in time.
    Love, Cloe

  • Shana,
    Loved your blog post & photos. I was tempted to skim the post,  like I do with most posts, but it was so intriguing that I read the whole thing – no skimming!
    I feel like niches are important to some people in some industries because it makes it easier to market and you can become a serious expert on that one thing. On the other hand for a lot of people (I would be included in those people) doing the same thing all the time can be more challenging than figuring out the best way to market multiple talents and promote the variety they can offer in their work. I think you should think about embracing your experience and the variety you can offer. You’ll be happier because you’ll be working more passionately and your clients will be delighted with the results!

  • Dear Shana:

    First of all, I love your questions.  They are so like you and when you find out some of the answers, just keep on asking more questions because I think that’s truly what your niche is.  You say it on your website, photos celebrating love and life.  A friend of mine said that, many years ago, she was leaving to be with her dying mother and a wise friend came over to her and said, ‘you’re not going there to help her die, you’re going there to help her live.’  And I think that is similar to what you do.  Your eye is on the life around you.  You shoot and comment on the lives you see in a wonderful way.  Just as Mary said, your photographs touch the heart.  Keep track of your income streams.  Try to find out which ones pay the most, not only in dollars, but in satisfaction, challenge, aesthetics.  And notice which areas give you the most heartburn.  And notice what time of year which ones happen.  Maybe your niche will become more clear.  And maybe you will have a seasonal focus.  Summer might become the time for weddings and graduations.  Fall might be the time for new beginnings.  And so on.  But track it all and see what happens.  I’d love to make a grid with you so you can keep track of all the different events — and lives — you shoot.  It might be really fun.  Or at least an excuse for a coffee at Woodstar.

    Love you,
    Jane

  • Shana,
    I love all of these thoughtful comments;) I think your questions are important ones not just for staying afloat financially but creatively. I think when you do what you love and are fulfilled your work will shine and in return your clients will love you. I like the idea of targeting a specific market for a time to see how that goes for you. I also think marketing your particular style is one way to go and show the best examples of life celebrations you’ve shot and turned into magical stories. I’m looking forward to further discussions because what I think really sells is being authentic, following your passion and plain ole hard work. You’re doing it girl!

  • [...] Niche of Not? (Shana Sureck, 5/23/11) (A photographer’s struggle to choose a niche, with great advice in the comments) [...]




*required